St. Petersburg Times
tampabay.com

Print storySubscribe to the Times

Profiles in Choice

Choice complicates a family decision

By CONSTANCE HUMBURG, Times Staff Writer
Published August 29, 2004

Situation: Times computer-assisted reporting specialist Constance Humburg gave up a sure public school path for her son to attend a Catholic high school.
(This article originally appeared Sept. 14, 2003)

When my son was finishing his last of nine years at St. Paul's Catholic School in St. Petersburg, we had to decide where he would go to high school.

"Choice" was a year away in the public school system, and neighborhoods were still zoned for schools. Oddly, that made the decision hard for us. Had we entered the public school system at that point, our son and his younger sister would have had seats reserved for them at a good public high school. If we waited, we would never again have a sure thing.

We were zoned for St. Petersburg High School, and we did like the IB program and the Advanced Placement courses the school offered. It was close by and part of the reason we bought our house near Crescent Lake. He also had classmates who would be going there.

Then we heard there would be 900 kids in the freshman class, and 200 would be repeating ninth grade. That seemed a bit overwhelming to the parent of a kid who had been in a school of 300 students K-8.

Years ago, we had sent our son to kindergarten at St. Paul's because it was a small, Catholic neighborhood school, and our friends recommended it. We felt Chris would be in a good place to learn because the strict rules would ensure that his classroom would not be chaotic. We also knew we wouldn't have to make another school choice until high school. By eighth grade we were looking forward to the end of tuition payments and were hoping to start saving more for college.

But the more we thought about Chris and where he would do best and considered his preference for St. Pete Catholic, we decided we should bite the bullet financially and send him there. We wanted him to have varied academic and extracurricular opportunities, to feel comfortable and not get lost in the crowd. It was the environment where we felt Chris would fit best while preparing him for college. Our daughter will be in eighth grade next year and we'll again make a decision about high school based on what is best for her particular strengths, temperament and learning style. And because of the choice we made for our older son, she won't have the benefit of an automatic slot at St. Pete High.

[Last modified August 24, 2004, 17:39:05]

School Search

Charter Schools
  • Education outside of the mainstream

  • High Schools
  • Advancing a career while in high school
  • Nine campuses offer range of practical career training
  • Where variety rules

  • Homeschooling
  • Pinellas friendly to homeschooling

  • How Busing Works
  • District streamlines system of getting kids to school

  • How To Apply
  • Applying just a phone call away
  • Online school choice form not for all
  • Pay close attention to avoid choice plan's pitfalls
  • The system's two-chambered heart
  • Two crucial calls for magnets, fundamentals, academies

  • How To Search
  • Nothing beats being there

  • Important Dates
  • Save these dates
  • School visit calendar

  • Information
  • A parent's primer to size up schools
  • New to the district? Register your child
  • The long and short of controlled choice
  • Want to switch schools? Options are limited

  • Information Centers
  • For more information

  • Middle Schools
  • Have a plan early

  • Overview
  • Learning the ways of choice or chance
  • Your navigation kit for the choice maze
  • Application is a risky business
  • Choose a good start
  • Key lesson of choice: Choose or lose
  • Pulling in the students with special interests
  • Schools attempt to raise their profiles
  • Screening, tests open access to gifted programs

  • Private Schools
  • A private matter
  • Some parents swear by voucher program

  • Profiles in Choice
  • Check out who sets agenda for the school
  • Choice complicates a family decision
  • Choice? Not really - let's just call it luck
  • Common bond is a big factor in a good school fit
  • Finding the right fit
  • Lesson learned: See it for yourself
  • Memories, values aid search for elementary
  • Not much of a choice for new residents
  • Planning, luck could deliver the best school
  • Private to public, small to really big
  • Sometimes where you are is the place to be
  • Sometimes you have to go with your gut
  • To get top choice, you may have to gamble
  • When your spouse is your kids' teacher . . .

  • Profiles in choice 2004
  • Approach choice like 'intelligent consumer'

  • Rookie Mom
  • First-year decisions draw child's big picture

  • School Grades
  • Behind each school grade is a deeper explanation
  • Dual programs hold schools accountable
  • For full story, include raw test scores
  • Making sense of the scores
  • To some, FCAT means more than just a score

  • Special Needs
  • Centers focus on needs
  • Programs help kids who may otherwise give up

  • The Computer Lottery
  • On waiting list? Patience is the key
  • Application process only the beginning
  • Students, parents face maze of choices

  • Click here for statistical data on Pinellas County schools

    Back to Top

    © 2006 • All Rights Reserved • St. Petersburg Times
    490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111